• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

USA Posts

Breaking News Stories from US and Around the World

  • Submit
  • Disclaimers
  • About
  • DMCA
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact
  • Show Search
Hide Search

You are here: Home / The Apple Card is just a credit card (and not a particularly special one)

The Apple Card is just a credit card (and not a particularly special one)

· November 13, 2019 ·

Welcome back to Tech Chronicle. There’s no cash-back reward if you subscribe, but I definitely offer a high interest rate.

Playing cards

Imagine, if you will, a credit card designed for online use, streamlined for digital use and stripped of unnecessary physical features.

I’m talking, of course, about Citibank’s ClickCredit card, introduced 20 years ago.

“It’s a totally new kind of payment tool, designed for the virtual world,” Antony Jenkins, the bank’s director of online initiatives, told IDG News at the time.

You can imagine my patented I’ve-seen-this-all-before eyeroll when Apple made carbon-copy promises about its new Apple Card two decades later. It has a security chip, like most modern credit cards, which wasn’t available when ClickCredit rolled out, but it also has a magnetic stripe, which no less an authority than Apple CEO Tim Cook has called “outdated and vulnerable.” ClickCredit did away with the stripe, anticipating a shiny future where e-commerce was everything.

The Apple Card is in the news now not for its spiffy new features but because famed programmer David Heinemeier Hansson complained that his wife, Jamie, was given a tiny line of credit on her Apple Card. Jamie Heinemeier Hansson noted that she has a higher credit score than her husband. A customer service representative blamed an “algorithm.” Apple co-founder Steve Wozniak said that he and his wife experienced a similar discrepancy in the credit lines they were granted.

Apple co-founder Steve Wozniak said his wife also experienced apparently discriminatory lending at the hands of Goldman Sachs, which is now being investigated by New York state regulators.

Photo: Wendy Lee / The Chronicle 2017

This isn’t Apple’s fault, though. Look to Goldman Sachs, the issuer of Apple-branded credit cards, which replaced longtime partner Barclays this year. For its trouble, Goldman (which has publicly denied any discrimination) is now being investigated by the New York State Department of Financial Services.

Plenty has been written about algorithmic discrimination, which is just as wrong as any kind of discrimination. But I think waving our hands about “algorithms” — which in this case is just credit scoring, a well-understood and long-established process in the financial world — obscures what happened here.

Apple wanted more control over the Apple Card in terms of its integration with the iPhone and Apple’s software. To gain that, it went with Goldman Sachs, which is a long-established commercial bank but a complete newbie to consumer credit. No one should be surprised if Goldman is making beginner mistakes that Citi, Chase and Bank of America have sorted out over decades of experience. Hopefully the scrutiny of regulators will make Goldman’s credit card managers fast students.

The Apple Card is primarily designed to used with Apple Pay, the contactless payment system in the iPhone and Apple Watch. But Apple and Goldman Sachs also offer a physical card.

Photo: Dwight Silverman / Houston Chronicle

I am reminded of Apple’s experience with the iPhone. To get more control over the phone, Steve Jobs negotiated with what was then known as Cingular —now AT&T Wireless — for an exclusive deal in exchange for an unusual amount of autonomy in hardware and software design. Apple even insisted on designing the radio, which explains why the early iPhone was infamous for dropping calls.

Consider these allegations of sexist credit limits the Apple Card’s dropped calls. AT&T’s experience with Apple should be telling: Within a few years, Jobs wriggled out of the exclusivity deal, having learned a lot about wireless networks and gaining leverage to force other carriers to accept its terms.

Sign Up for the Newsletter

Want to get the latest on Silicon Valley in your inbox? Subscribe to Tech Chronicle.

Read More

The Apple Card is just a way for Apple to get deeper into the credit card business, using Goldman just as long as it needs to. Its real goal — if history is any indication — is to get the big, established credit card issuers to adopt its new security and privacy features. (Maybe they’ll use more mature credit systems, too — ones that don’t make newbie mistakes that land them in trouble with regulators.)

At that point, any card could be an Apple card. Heck, maybe Apple should talk to Citi about issuing one, since it has 20 years of experience with virtual cards.

They can call it iCredit.

— Owen Thomas, [email protected]

Quote of the week

“You’re f—ing with the magic.” — Viacom CEO Mel Karmazin to Google’s co-founders on their ideas for advertising in 2003, according to the Correspondent

Coming up

Dreamforce, that annual exercise in people feigning helpless ignorance about what Salesforce does as 170,000 flood the streets of San Francisco, starts Tuesday. (In case you’re genuinely confused, here’s a primer: Businesses need software to operate. Salesforce provides much of that software. If you’re a consumer, you almost certainly don’t pay Salesforce for its software, but you also probably work for or shop at a business that does.)

What I’m reading

Related Stories

  • By Shahien Nasiripour and Sridhar Natarajan

    Apple co-founder says Goldman’s Apple Card algorithm…

  • Biz & Tech
    Taylor Telford, The Washington Post

    Apple Card algorithm sparks gender bias allegations against…

  • Technology

    NY regulator vows to investigate Apple Card for sex bias

Judd Legum reveals that Facebook’s top media liaison, Campbell Brown, has a news site that has been bashing Facebook critic and Democratic presidential candidate Elizabeth Warren. (Popular Information)

Catherine Ho digs into Juul’s plan to cut spending and lay off workers amid widespread crackdowns on vaping. (San Francisco Chronicle)

Keach Hagey and Vivien Ngo offer a visual explainer of Google’s dominance of the online advertising market. (Wall Street Journal)

Tech Chronicle is a thrice-weekly newsletter from Owen Thomas, The Chronicle’s business editor, and the rest of the tech team. Follow along on Twitter: @techchronicle and Instagram: @techchronicle

  • Former Apple CEO John Sculley is working on a startup that he thinks could become bigger than Apple
  • The 25 best tech companies to work for in 2016, according to employees
  • These 11 startups are re-inventing how money works and they’re worth more than $1 billion
  • The 22 biggest tech scandals of 2016

Filed Under: Business Jamie Heinemeier Hansson, Steve Wozniak, David Heinemeier Hansson, Antony Jenkins, Tim Cook, Mel Karmazin, Elizabeth Warren, AT&, T, Steve Jobs, Keach Hagey, Owen Thomas, @techchronicle, Judd Legum, Campbell Brown, Catherine Ho, Juul, Vivien Ngo, San Fr, prepaid card and credit card, prepaid card or credit card, leaked credit card numbers 2019, 0 cash advance fee credit card, paying with paypal without credit card, when paying the minimum on credit card, yatra sbi credit card, credit card where to sign, 806 restraint credit card, quicksilver unsecured credit card, business cards credit, pre qualified credit cards bad credit, credit card receivable financing, am i personally liable for a business credit card, low interest rate business credit cards, business account credit cards, guaranteed approval credit cards bad credit, does cancelling a credit card hurt your credit, does cancelling a credit card hurt your credit score, authorized user credit card build credit, credit card with 0 balance transfer for 12 months, student credit card capital one, capitol one student credit card, capital one student credit cards, capital one student credit card, student credit cards no credit, student credit card no credit, student credit cards bad credit, student credit card bad credit, credit cards okay credit

Primary Sidebar

RSS Recent Stories

  • The Main Reasons Why A Driver Can Pay Really Expensive Car Insurance Premiums
  • Quirk Volkswagen offers special coupons on VW accessories during December 2019
  • Colombia’s ‘Valley of Souls’ Wins Marrakech’s Etoile d’Or
  • Award-winning rapper and activist Common hosts concert at California Rehabilitation Center
  • NFL At 100: Rooney Rule has its positives and its faults
Copyright © 2019 USA Posts. Power by Wordpress.