OAKLAND, Calif., July 17 (Reuters) – After a 19-year legal struggle, three former makers of lead paint have agreed to a $305 million settlement with California county and city governments to mitigate poisoning dangers still present in old housing.
Under the deal, disclosed in a filing in Santa Clara County Superior Court on Wednesday, defendants Sherwin-Williams , Conagra Brands Inc and NL Industries agreed to pay out the sum over six years, starting with a $75 million payment later this year.
The defendant paint companies did not admit any wrongdoing under the settlement.
Most of the money will go toward a remediation program to eliminate lead paint hazards in older homes across the 10 jurisdictions that participated in the suit. These include Los Angeles, San Francisco, Alameda, and Santa Clara counties, as well as individual cities such as Oakland and San Diego.
During the litigation, the plaintiffs had sought a far larger judgment mandating removal of lead paint from hundreds of thousands of older homes. Just how many homes can be made safer with the settlement funds isn’t clear.
Last year, Santa Clara County Superior Court estimated that inspecting one housing unit would cost around $140 on average, while lead paint remediation would cost around $1,500 per unit.
Some of the settlement money – 17% – is also due to outside counsel hired by local governments during the case.
The home clean-up program will be free for property owners who qualify to participate, and officials have said the remediation efforts could prevent thousands of new lead exposure cases.
The local governments first brought the lawsuit in 2000 with the aim of making the companies pay billions for the clean-up. They claimed the companies knew of the toxic dangers of lead paint when they marketed it for decades before the U.S. government banned its use in homes in 1978.
The companies contended they did not continue marketing leaded paints once the risks were known. They also argued that private property owners were responsible for the upkeep of homes to ensure potential paint hazards would not harm residents.
The settlement represents a rare success for plaintiffs suing paint companies under the so-called public nuisance doctrine, which allows public entities to sue parties whose activities negatively impact broad communities by infringing upon a public right.
Public nuisance cases against former lead paint makers have failed in other states, including Rhode Island, Illinois and Missouri.
Still, the $305 million falls far short of what the plaintiffs had counted on until recently. In a 2014 trial verdict, the companies were ordered to pay $1.15 billion, but in 2017 an appeals court decision led to the judgment being reduced to $409 million. Taken together, the court decisions also restricted how the money could be spent.
For instance, the funds could only be used to fix paint hazards in the interior of homes built before 1951, though lead paint continued to be sold into the 1970s and exterior paint also harms children. The plaintiffs had also faced a short, four-year window to complete the clean-up program, after which unspent funds would be returned to the companies.
In striking a compromise for a lesser amount, the California jurisdictions managed to get those terms lifted, giving them more leeway and no time constraint on using the remediation funds, the court filing showed. (Reporting By Joshua Schneyer Editing by Michael Williams and Ross Colvin)
- Coronavirus live updates: Supreme Court upholds California’s right to restrict religious services
- Coronavirus live updates: Trump ends U.S. relationship with World Health Organization
- Coronavirus live updates: Nearly 4,000 dead across California as reopening efforts advance
- Coronavirus live updates: New report suggests virus began to spread in California in January
- The Hill's Coronavirus Report: Geopolitical adviser Parag Khanna criticizes US, China leadership on virus; US COVID-19 cases reach highest single-day level
- The Short, Hard Life Of Freddie Gray
- Column: Citing coronavirus, Sutter seeks to renege on ‘historic’ antitrust deal
- Amber Heard called Elon Musk her 'Rocketman' while texting the SpaceX chief BEFORE she filed for divorce from Johnny Depp, new messages reveal
- George Floyd latest: Washington DC protesters arrive for 'largest' rally
- Coronavirus live updates: San Francisco financial scenarios ‘keep getting worse every week’
- Coronavirus live updates: Apple’s Genius help, store pickups return in Bay Area
- In the Valley of the Shadow of Death: Guyana After the Jonestown Massacre
|Incase Simple Snap Case for iPhone 6 - Made in California5.0★ / $7.99||Apple iPhone SE 5 5c 5s 6 6s (Fits 16GB 32GB 64GB) Mobile Wallet Clutch Designed in California4.6★ / check it now at Amazon||A Death In California (Tvm)4.5★ / $14.99||Deep Purple: Live in California '74 - The DVD Archive Collection4.0★ / $7.47||Portuguese in California Documentary4.8★ / $28.73||How to Paint Leaves - DVD - Step-by-step in Detail - 5 Leaf Studies5.0★ / check it now at Amazon||Meet Mary Pleasant, Mother of Civil Rights in California4.4★ / check it now at Amazon||Historic Travel US San Francisco A Jewel In California's Crown4.3★ / $14.5||deep purple live in california 74 dvd Italian Import5.0★ / $5.61||Historic Travel US Learning To Live In California5.0★ / $19.95||HARMONIUM - IN CALIFORNIA2.0★ / $5.99||Crayola Paint Maker check it now at Amazon||Puzzle Makers International Large Format Glow in the Dark Shaped Jigsaw Puzzle - 300 Pieces - Deer By The Cabin check it now at Amazon||Cowboy Billy Clanton Gunfight at the O.K. Corral Tombstone Series 1/32 Scale Painted Metal Toy Soldier Figure New in Box FW307 check it now at Amazon||Virgil Earp Gunfight at the O.K. Corral Tombstone Series I'm Hit 1/32 Scale Painted Metal Toy Soldier Figure New in Box FW305 check it now at Amazon||Crayola Paint Maker Refill packs check it now at Amazon||Crayola Pink Paint Maker check it now at Amazon||Dinosaur Pen's. Hand Painted Writing Pens. Set of 4 in Case check it now at Amazon||Hagen-Renaker Papa Cat, Black and White Feline Figurine Hand-Crafted, Hand-Painted in California USA.5.0★ / check it now at Amazon||Art 101 Painting with Oils and Acrylics 101 in Wooden Case check it now at Amazon||Vintage Ignignokt - Mooninites Painting Creative And Regular Short Sleeve In Gray check it now at Amazon||Da Vinci Hand Painted Poker Card Guard Protector, All In with Gold Background check it now at Amazon||Da Vinci Hand Painted Poker Card Guard Protector, All In with Black Background5.0★ / check it now at Amazon||Vintage Plaid Playing Cards in California Blue by Dan & Dave2.0★ / check it now at Amazon||The Rodney King Case - What the Jury Saw in California v. Powell [VHS]5.0★ / $29.75||Heaven's Gate: Culticide in California [VHS]2.3★ / $18.99||Sierra Nevada In California by Albert Bierstadt Canvas Painting Reproduction Art Print #1488 40"x26" check it now at Amazon||Sierra Nevada In California by Albert Bierstadt Canvas Painting Reproduction Art Print #1492 40"x26" check it now at Amazon||The Russian settlement in California known as Fort Ross, founded 1812, abandoned 1841: why the Russians came and why they left$15.75||Masters of Light: Plein-Air Painting in California 1890-1930 check it now at Amazon|
Paint makers reach $305 mln settlement in California, ending marathon lead poisoning lawsuit have 1113 words, post on www.reuters.com at July 17, 2019. This is cached page on USA Posts. If you want remove this page, please contact us.